"Economics forces us to confront a fundamental symmetry. The conflict arises because each side wants to allocate the same resource in a different way. Jack wants his woodland at the expense of Jill's parking space and Jill wants her parking space at the expense of Jack's woodland. That formulation is morally neutral and should serve as a warning against assigning exalted moral status to either Jack or Jill."He is right to say that the formulation is "morally neutral" but is exercising one's preference for woodland not morally superior to that of a parking spot? It may very well be if we are talking about a specific plot of land say in Yellowstone National Park, which I will return to briefly.
Matt Ridley in The Rational Optimist writes:
Whether considering fish off Iceland, kudu in Namibia, jaguars in Mexico, trees in Niger, bees in Bolivia or water in Colorado, the same lesson applies. Give local people the power to own, exploit and profit from natural resources in a sustainable way and they will usually preserve and cherish those resources. Give them no share in a wildlife resource that is controlled – nay ‘protected’ – by a distant government and they will generally neglect, ruin and waste it.Notice the qualifiers "in a sustainable way," "usually," and "generally." Is it not the case that we are better off keeping our national parks just that- national? What if Montana chooses to build a large amusement park in its share of Yellowstone National Park instead of maintaining the land "in a sustainable way?"
Perhaps, Montana should empower its own localities to determine what they want to do with park land. After all, Montana is not as distant a government from the park as the federal government and as the argument implies, locals know how to manage the land better. Those that surround the land can divvy it up and decide what is the best economic use of it so that the revenue no longer goes to the federal government in the form of visitor fees but in the form of tickets for amusement park rides, private airports, mines, etc. And if that means that there is nothing left of the park land, so be it. At least locals were empowered and have found ways to exploit the land for economic gain.
But what about the preference of tourists and future generations of them to take in the beauty and the air of the land? Wouldn't that be objectionable to them? Wouldn't it be objectionable to scientists who can no longer access the land because it is owned and put to use by locals? Can anyone certify that scientists have learned everything there is to know about soil?
I am of the opinion that one of the greatest strengths that the United States has its national parks system. I want places to go to that I do not see a town or any sign of civilization for miles on end. Local empowerment heightens the risk of losing aesthetic beauty to the extent that it calls for development. I venture to guess that Jared Diamond, the author of Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed would agree. Covering Montana in the first chapter, Diamond writes:
While concern is mounting in Montana about runoff of fertilizer, manure, septic tank contents, and herbicides, by far the biggest toxic waste issue is posed by residues from metal mining, some of it from the last century and some of it recent or ongoing. Metal mining-especially of copper, but also of lead...-stood as one of the traditional pillars of Montana's economy. No one disagrees that mining is essential, somewhere and somehow: modern civilization and its chemical, construction, electric, and electronic industries run on metals. Instead, the question is where and how best to mine metal-bearing ores."Jared Diamond clearly recognizes the importance of economic development. Nonetheless, he goes on to say that some mining companies deny responsibility for leeching harmful chemicals into the environment, thereby passing the buck to taxpayers, and passing the real bucks to shareholders living outside the state of Montana. Some residents of the state have even said that they were better off importing some of the coal from these mines from Chile when comparing the costs of cleaning up to the price tag on the imports.
The larger point here is that there must be a balance between federal control over land and state/local control. I personally like the status quo of the federal park system. Whether large tracts of land in Maine should now become a federal park is something that merits debate. The Department of the Interior and the state will hopefully be able to reach a compromise so as to balance economic development with maintaining aesthetics.
Pursuing profit does not necessarily spell doom to the environment; in fact, it can promote its preservation. For example, more trees are grown to support paper production than would occur in its absence. Both Landsburg and Ridley can share a multitude of examples on this end. Just read their books if you are interested in just how. Jeffrey Sach's Common Wealth would not disagree with those examples but would add that there are negative externalities since prices do not reflect true costs to citizens. What is not clear is what specific actions we should take and at which levels. Ridley cites that the rate at which species are dying is highly overstated, the growth of the human population is dwindling and so the population itself will stabilize in this century and that there is constant negotiation being made between the earth and its inhabitants. We are misled to believe that it would not be otherwise if we weren't here.
I like Jeffrey Sach's label "cautious optimist." He even points out the possibility of sucking carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and sequestering it. Combining this with Matt Ridley's love and belief in technology and how the collective brain capitalizes on it so as to increase our wealth, I too am an optimist- somewhere between a cautious one and a rational one.
Although Ridley makes the compelling argument that the pursuit of wealth actually benefits the environment, he does concede to environmentalists that the quality of crops may not be as good as it used to be. He has a solution to this problem but it does not fully redress the problem. This will have to be in a separate posting on nutrition, farming policy and their connection to our health.